Home › Is it really them calling? › First Federal Savings of Middletown
Checked October 29, 2026.
Is that really First Federal Savings of Middletown calling or texting me?
Short answer
Maybe, but don't trust the call or text to tell you. Banks, including First Federal Savings of Middletown, may contact customers about possible fraud, and scammers copy its name and fake its caller ID. Hang up, then call the number on the back of your card or open the official First Federal Savings of Middletown app yourself.
Treat it as a scam if the caller or text asks you to: read out a one-time code, give your full password or PIN, move money to a "safe" or "new" account, send money with Zelle to "fix" fraud, or install an app so they can see your screen.
Official facts about First Federal Savings of Middletown
- Legal name: First Federal Savings of Middletown
- FDIC certificate number: 28712
- Headquarters: Middletown, New York
- Official website (from FDIC records): www.firstfederalmiddletown.com
- Established: January 1, 1888
- Offices: 1 (1 in the U.S.)
Source: FDIC BankFind, certificate 28712 (data as of June 30, 2026, pulled October 29, 2026).
Official ways to reach First Federal Savings of Middletown
Use the number on the back of your card or on your statement, or find a number on its official website, www.firstfederalmiddletown.com (the address on file with the FDIC; type it in yourself). Dial it yourself; don't call back a number from a text or voicemail.
We haven't checked First Federal Savings of Middletown's own contact page yet, so we don't list its phone numbers here.
Signing in? Type the bank's address yourself instead of tapping a link in a message.
First Federal Savings of Middletown by the numbers
- Total assets: $188.0 million
- Total deposits: $112.3 million
- Primary federal regulator: Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC)
- Headquarters county: Orange County
Source: FDIC BankFind institution data (report date 06/30/2026; dollar figures are as reported to the FDIC, pulled October 29, 2026).
Where First Federal Savings of Middletown has offices
The FDIC lists 1 office for First Federal Savings of Middletown in 1 state or territory. A real branch can confirm whether a call came from the bank.
NY
- 22 James St, Middletown, NY 10940 (Orange County) (main office)
Source: FDIC BankFind locations, pulled October 29, 2026.
Earlier legal names
Scammers sometimes use an old name. The FDIC records these legal name changes for First Federal Savings of Middletown:
- January 25, 1995: First Federal Savings and Loan Association of Middletown became First Federal Savings of Middletown
Source: FDIC BankFind history (change code 510), pulled October 29, 2026.
Area codes near First Federal Savings of Middletown's locations
Phone exchanges in the towns where First Federal Savings of Middletown has offices use these area codes: 329, 845, 914. A caller ID showing one of them proves nothing on its own, since caller ID can be faked, but each link shows the numbers people have reported in that area code.
Source: NANPA central office code assignments (file dated October 28, 2026), matched by rate center to office towns.
Scripts scammers use, and how to report one
The fake "fraud department" call, the "safe account" transfer, the Zelle "reversal" and the code request work the same way whatever name the caller uses. Read them in our guide to bank and company impostor scripts, with the places to report a call or text.
Last checked: October 29, 2026
FraudMeNot is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by First Federal Savings of Middletown. Names are used only to identify the company. Complaint counts are public government data and are not a judgment about the company.